A Time for Thanksgiving

As we move into the US holiday season, my wife, Shirley, has the following contribution. Her words are a prelude to our upcoming memoir, Faith in Crisis – How God Shows Up When You Need Him Most.

At this time of the year our thoughts turn to thankfulness. We encourage children  to think about what they are thankful for – food, a home, parents who love them, various family members, even the privilege of an education.

As adults we can take nothing for granted. I have felt challenged to see how God has been in every detail of my life from the very beginning to draw me to Himself. I would challenge each one of us to look back on our lives and identify the Lord’s guidance and protection.

Each of us has a story to tell. I worked as a social worker with the underprivileged and at one point with sexually abused girls, so I have heard many stories. I would like to share just one aspect of my story of how God prepared us for our Elizabeth.

I never knew my parents, but my grandmother brought me up in her Christian home.  She told me I had a little brother that only lived a few days after birth. This was only a reminder to me when the question came up whenever I was pregnant if there had been any disabilities at birth in my family.

Jeremiah 29:11 states: “For I know the thoughts that I think toward you, says the Lord, thoughts of peace and not of evil, to give you a future and a hope.

When we lived in Kuwait there was a little girl who had been a twin. Her parents abused her and caused her to have a head injury and therefore very limited intelligence. She was in the hospital where Jim worked. Our children went to visit her and although she was Muslim the hospital granted us special permission to take her to our home. She would stay with us days at a time. Soon we came to regard her as part of our family and developed a special love for her. When it was time for us to return to Augusta for summer break we were sadly informed that we could not take her out of the country. Since she was Muslim it was impossible for us to adopt her. After the war with Iraq our Kuwaiti friends told us that her biologic parents killed her.

We thought about adopting a special needs baby but I told the adoption agency I could not handle a child who could not walk or one that was mentally challenged.

When we heard about a baby with one arm and crossed eyes this seemed fine because these things could be fixed. However, upon her arrival we realized that the problems were much greater than this. Although we wondered how even with the Lord I could ever handle this child, we clung to Romans 8:28: “And we know that all things work together for good to those who love God, to those who are called according to His purpose.”
What a blessing the Lord has given us in this child. Her simple joy and trust in the Lord and enthusiasm for life pushes me ahead every day. The Lord had certainly brought good above anything I could ever ask or think.  She tells us her job in life is: “to tell others about Christ. ”

Although many cannot understand Elizabeth when she speaks, her love for others and concern for them is obvious. If there is an accident on the road or an emergency vehicle, she never fails to want to pray for them. I admit I am sometimes embarrassed when she wants to pray for complete strangers who have expressed a need or might just have a cast on a part of their body. When I am with a friend who might express a concern or need, she is always ready to tell them a Bible verse that would meet that concern. God has revealed His glory through all his creation. Praise the lord for His sovereignty and His great love for us.

 

The Bidoon of Kuwait and the Bidoon of the US

The word “bidoon” in Arabic means “without.” The Bidoon comprise about 100,000 of Kuwait’s three million population. They are the descendants of Bedouins who failed to register for citizenship early in the history of Kuwait. Thus, they lack status as citizens. They are essentially stateless with no hope of altering their position. They do not receive welfare, healthcare, or free education. They cannot vote.

The Bidoon, in a small number, have joined other Middle Eastern refugees seeking asylum in Europe.

But most Bidoon remain where they have grown up in Kuwait. They are a class to themselves in that rich Gulf State.

I know what you’re thinking. The rich Kuwaitis should award citizenship to the Bidoon of Kuwait.

Do we in the US have our own class of Bidoon? Among those children of undocumented aliens who have grown up in this country, we see a similar group.

Should both Kuwait and the US provide a path to citizenship for these stateless ones?

 

 

How the Arabs of the Great Peninsula See Their Origin

While there is no singular view among the Arabs about their ancestors and their place of origin, the following is a view many would adopt. The excerpt below is from my unpublished novel Kuwaiti Seeker in the words of its protagonist, Yacoub. You will note that Yacoub combines ideas from both the Quran and the Old Testament.

“This is how our people came to be. Those who long preceded us came from our own place, where we now reside [the Arabian peninsula]. Our ancestors proceeded north and settled the fertile land between the two great rivers, dispossessing those less able than ourselves, for we are by nature invaders and not defenders. Through our own driven efforts of generation, we spawned the Jews.

“Our great father and prophet, Noah, told the people ‘Ask forgiveness from your Lord; for He is oft-forgiving (The Meaning of the Holy Qur’an, Abdullah Yusef Ali, 71.10).’ For Noah knew their misdeeds. And ‘What is the matter with you, that ye place not your hope for kindness and long-suffering in Allah (71.13)?’ And more, Noah said, ‘O my Lord! They have disobeyed me, but they follow (men) whose wealth and children give them no increase but only loss. (71.21).’ Our father Noah warned the people but they did not look to Allah. ‘Because of their sins they were drowned (in the flood), and were made to enter the Fire (of Punishment): and they found – in lieu of Allah – none to help them. (71.25).’

“The book of the Jews and Christians tells us Noah’s son, Shem, came next. We are all sons of Shem [hence, both Arabs and Jews are Semites]. Shem was righteous and covered his father’s nakedness preserving the honor of our tribe. His descendant Eber gave life to Peleg and Joktan. Eber means ‘divide’, and in the time of Eber the peoples of the earth were divided by language. But through Eber the thread of language that binds us to the other sons of Shem was preserved.

“Peleg and Joktan wandered (know now that we come by this trait rightly). From Pelelg came Abraham who lived first in the hilly desert not more than a day’s drive north of our diwaniya [discussion group characteristic of Kuwait] tonight. His ziggurat of Ur is still seen in the wind-blown desert. Abraham preached the worship of Allah to his father, Azar, who did not believe the truth. So Abraham left him. He proved his faith when he agreed to sacrifice Ishmael [Christians say Issac], who was saved only through the will of Allah. Ishmael’s mother Hagar took him away from the spiteful Sarah and into the waterless desert. Once again Allah preserved them when the spring of Zamzam came out of the ground. It was there that Abraham and Ishmael built our holy house, and Allah sanctified the Kaaba. And it is there we return for our pilgrimage.

“Out of the tent of Abraham and Ishmael came our progenitor Adnan and out of his tent, Mohammed. And the northern desert of our great peninsula yielded to them. We still picture Adnan as he has become in our memories: long-faced, unperturbed, difficult but strong and brave, the long curved nose marking his demeanor, such that he came to resemble the Hurr falcon which he used to hunt the houbara bustard.

“Out of Eber, also, had come Joktan. The people of Joktan traveled south around the great desert, along the western coast of the Red Sea. Like their father Yoktan, they were fleshy, round-faced and full of sloth. They settled in the Hadramawt, which is the place of death.”

Proxy War Continues in Yemen – And Nobody Cares

Iran supplies the Houthis of Yemen, a Shite subgroup, with arms to fight the Sunni regime in Saudi Arabia. The Saudis continue to bomb Yemeni targets. In support of Saudi Arabia, the US and allies attempt to interrupt the flow of Iranian arms.

An event earlier this year was typical. According to the Navy statement, the US warships Sirocco and Gravely seized a small boat carrying 1,500 AK-47 rifles, 200 rocket-propelled grenade (RPG) launchers, and 21 .50-caliber machine guns.  Small Gulf crafts called dhows transport most of the shipments,  and there is no way  to monitor all such vessels in the Gulf.

The news of the ongoing war surfaces only rarely in popular news. After all, it is only the Yemenis who are suffering, and the world has already lost interest and given up on them. They have no oil for us.

The only possible risk for us from the Yemenis is the damage they might inflict on shipping at the Bab Al-Mandeb, where vessels enter the Red Sea from the Gulf of Aden. And the US Navy can handle that with little difficulty.

Never mind that the Yemenis are the only ones suffering in this proxy war. Never mind that the country we think of as just another desert is not all desert, but rather some of the most beautiful land on earth.

yemen3

Never mind that the real wealth of the country, the people who want for their children the same things we want for our children, is not considered.

After all, this stuff is happening only in the Middle East. Do you think we should care?

 

Is It Wahhabism That’s Causing the Problem?

What’s the reason for the upsurge in violence that many associate with Islam? Is the doctrine promulgated by Mohammed Ibn Abd-Al Wahhab in the 1700s the source of the problem? The name Wahhabism is often linked with the current violence in the Middle East. What is the connection, if any, between the doctrine and the violence?

Wahhab’s central teaching was the uniqueness and unity of God. Anything that contradicted or detracted from that principle constituted sin and an affront to God.

Although modern proponents are often referred to as Wahhabists, they oppose that name, apparently due to the view that to do so venerates ibn Wahhab. Thus, use of the man’s name undermines the central idea of the doctrine. They may prefer to be called Salafi Muslims, loosely meaning that they adhere to the earliest doctrines of Islam.

But to the political aspects. Almost from its earliest days, the doctrine was politicized. As the doctrine came of age in the great Arabian peninsula desert, it was adopted by the House of Saud. These early rulers used the doctrine in their attempts to evangelize and control the people of the desert. Abdul-Aziz Ibn Saud, the father of modern Saudi Arabia, brought to the table the highest level of political skill in achieving dominance of the land. He used the doctrine to his advantage as a tool to promote his own brand of leadership.

Beginning in the early 1900s Ibn Saud recruited a group of desert warriors to carry out his will in the name of the Wahhabi or Salafi doctrine. The Ikhwan, or Brethren, took on a brand of war unheard of among the desert tribes: they killed women and children. Only when the Ikhwan exceeded Saud’s political control, by invading areas where he saw no advantage, did Saud intervene. He used motor vehicles and modern weapons, eschewed by the Ikhwan on the basis of doctrine, to control and eventually extinguish his desert warriors. Once again the political aspects held sway over doctrine. But not before innocent lives were sacrificed. A weapon as sharp as the doctrine of the unity of God must be used with care and great skill. Even the great Ibn Saud was not fully up to the task.

Is there any difference today? I contend that the violence we see today in the name of Islam is political, not doctrinal. Still, Saudi Arabia is trying to walk the balance beam of Wahhabi doctrine. Will they stab themselves by falling on the same sword?

I offer one example. I cannot verify the translation of Quranic Arabic myself, but I trust the work of David Commins in his book, The Wahhabi Mission and Saudi Arabia. The Saudis participate in the distribution of an English translation of the Quran in US mosques. The literal translation of a passage reads:

O Prophet, tell your wives, daughters and the women of believers to lower (or possibly, draw upon themselves) their garments. This is better so that they will not  be known or molested.  And, God is forgiving and merciful.

The Wahhabi version reads:

O Prophet! Tell your wives and daughters and the women of the believers to draw their cloaks (veils) all over their bodies (i.e. screen themselves completely except the eyes or one eye to see the way). That will be better, that they should be known (as free respectable women) so as not to be annoyed.  And Allah is Ever Oft-Forgiving, Most Merciful.

[in a Western context, the mention of God’s mercy in this situation may seem strange, but verses from the Quran frequently make this allusion.]

The distribution, of the Wahhabi translation by the Saudi government, must be considered a political decision. Otherwise, why would they not distribute a literal translation of the word the Prophet Mohammed? After all, Mohammed told us the Quran was delivered as a dictation from God.

I think it’s the politics that gets us in trouble, not the doctrine.

But my wife has a different view. When we lived in Kuwait, she had strong personal relationships with the Bedouin women of the Murra tribe. She tells the following story.

During our time in Kuwait, there occurred the murder of a young woman and her newborn baby by the brother of the woman’s husband. The woman had conceived the pregnancy by a man other than her husband. The murderer was never charged. The event was ripe for discussion.  My wife was surprised to learn that two of the young women with whom she was close, and actually friends of the murdered woman, supported the murders, even that of the innocent infant. The young women expressed the practical concern that there would be no one who would care for the baby born in such sin. The baby’s murder was therefore the only option. The two young women knew my wife disagreed. Their response: “As you learn more about God, you will understand.”

For them, the issue was not political. It was from their hearts. This was what they believed at a deep level.

So, perhaps there is more than just the politics.

 

The Trees in the Garden

Both the Bible and the Quran address the subject of trees in the Garden of Eden. While the accounts differ in some respects, vital concepts arise.

The Bible names two trees among the number in the Garden: the Tree of Life and the Tree of the Knowledge of Good and Evil. God allowed Adam and Eve access to the Tree of Life but not to the Tree of the Knowledge of Good and Evil. Eve, who accepted the lie of the serpent, gave the fruit to Adam, and both ate from the tree. As a consequence, God put a curse on them and expelled them from the Garden, preventing any further access to the sustenance provided by the Tree of Life.

Among the trees of Eden, only one is specifically mentioned in the Quran: the Tree of Eternity or Immortality. While this tree seems analogous to the Bible’s Tree of Life, the God of the Quran forbade access to the Tree of Eternity. When Adam and Eve disobeyed after they believed the counsel of the devil, they were forgiven, but they were expelled from the Garden. God did not deliver a curse upon them. The other main difference in the Quran account is that Eve was not mentioned by name nor was she blamed as the one at fault.

The trees of Eden are still prominent symbols for us. The concept of Tree of Life and the Tree of Knowledge pervades many religions and cultures,  The two trees may be considered as one tree or two trees. I have seen two trees so-designated in my Middle East travels.

In Bahrain, out in the desert a short distance from Manama, I saw a lonely mesquite tree referred to as the Tree of Life.

index

The tree is estimated to be about 400 years old.The tree lies near an archeological site believed to be from the Dilmun era, which was mentioned as early as 3000 BC, and possibly referred to in the Epic of Gilgamesh (ca. 2000 BC) as a “Paradise.”

In the little town of Al-Qurna near Nasiriya in southern Iraq, I observed the jujube tree called the Tree of Knowledge. The sign, in English, in front of the tree says “Adam’s Tree”. Somehow appropriate, the tree is dead.

tok02

What are the takeaway messages from the Tree(s)? The first is that God must know something we don’t know. We no longer possess access to the real Tree of Life or the wisdom of the Tree of Knowledge. The second point is that we lost these resources through disobedience to God.

Among the religions of the world the only two possible solutions are typified by what’s seen in Islam on one hand and Christianity on the other.

Islam presents the noble idea that we must strive to please God and that through this endeavor we may regain what we lost. We may be able to solve the problem through our own efforts. which must be of the highest quality.

Christianity, in contrast, says we are unable to solve the problem. God must solve it for us, and this can only be done through the perfect work of Jesus.

I can’t think of any other possible solutions besides these two.

The Man From Ur

“You are the LORD God, who chose Abram and brought him out of Ur of the Chaldeans and named him Abraham.” (NIV, Nehemiah 9:7)

In 2003, just after the US-led attack on Iraq, we traveled as a medical relief team to southern Iraq around the Basra area. As we knew Ur was nearby, we took a day off and went on a search for the proposed site just out of Nasiriya. We located it and got close enough for a photo.

Abraham's Tomb at Ur

The ziggurat of Ur is barely seen in the middle of the photo on top of the hill.  We got no closer. The area was guarded by our soldiers.

Soldier at Ur

How peculiar our boys were sent around the world to fight a war and ended up protecting Abraham’s birth place and the preserved monument to the moon god, Nanna. We surrendered to the superior force and retreated.

A short way out of Ur we encountered a man and a woman herding camels. The man was walking and his beautiful, much younger wife (or daughter) rode their camel. When they saw us as we stopped to gawk, the woman dismounted, and they both motioned for us to come over for a camel ride, for a price of course.

noble arab

But two interesting things struck me. First, the man allowed the young woman to ride while he walked. Second, the man was severely disabled. A close-up of his lower legs revealed marked muscle atrophy and foot drops.

foot drop

As a neurologist, I can firmly state he was afflicted by severe sensorimotor neuropathy. Yet he insisted the young woman ride. I considered this a noble act on his part.

More than 4000 years have passed since Abraham departed Ur at the Lord’s command. Yet we know that man, that is, every man and woman, is created in the image of God. Perhaps of some Abraham’s DNA  still roams the area around Ur.

Is There Any Hope For Yemen?

Yemen mountain village
Yemen mountain village

I visited Yemen numerous times over the years as I worked with an NGO there. The little country at the tip of the Arabian peninsula was a mix of starkly beautiful mountains, the old city in Sanaa with its gingerbread architecture, stone villages on hilltops, and ill kept countryside with trash strewn throughout the landscape.

Even at its best one could tell the country was doomed. The greatest long-term concern was its shortage of water. The country could not afford desalinization facilities. They even entertained the idea of towing an iceberg down from the Arctic. And the shortage was compounded by the cultivation of qat ,which required much of the available ground water. Virtually all the populace chews the mildly narcotic plant. Indeed, all the resources of the country were stretched by the population growth rate that exceeded the capacity of the country to support itself. For the time I was there, it appeared the country was on a slow downward spiral.

Then, things got worse. The so-called Arab spring forced then president Abdullah Al-Saleh to resign in 2011. In 2014 civil war developed between Houthi rebels and the new Hadi government. Hadi subsequently set up a Sunni based government in exile in Aden in the south, and the Houthis, a Ziadi/Shia-based group allied with the former president, Al-Saleh, took over the Sanaa area. Because of their fear of a Shia based group on their southern border, Saudi Arabia began bombing Houthi sites. This conflict has led to further disaster in the country with increasing loss of civilian lives and damage to the country’s sad infrastructure. The situation is further complicated by the rise of Al-Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula (AQAP), a Sunni-based group from southern Yemen.

On the international front, the big concern is whether the overall Yemen conflict is in fact a proxy war between Saudi Arabia backing Sunni elements and Iran backing the Shia groups. Certainly Saudi Arabia has guns in the fight, and as far as news reports are concerned, the Saudis are causing much damage to the country. The role of Iran is less clear.

What can be done? The real question is whether any one cares. The answer is: no one of any importance cares. The conflict in Yemen presently has little effect on our economics or oil supply. The minor concern is that the entry for oil shipping into the Red Sea could be blocked at the Bab Al-Mandab, thus obstructing traffic to and from the Suez Canal, but frankly that result is unlikely.

The Shia/Sunni divide may be the fuel for the conflict, with Saudi and Iran carrying the current torches. The theological, social, and economic differences between the two argue against solution.

The Bedouins of Kuwait 1988-90

My wife Shirley writes:

It was a privilege to get to know some of the Bedouins of the Al-Murrah tribe when we lived in Kuwait in 1988-1990.  Another American family had lived many years in Kuwait and introduced me to the Bedouin women.  They showed me the clothes we needed in order to visit the Bedouins respectfully.  All children under twelve went with me to the women to visit while Jim went to visit the men.  We were accepted since Jim was their doctor at the hospital in Kuwait City.

I tried to learn Arabic, and although I took classes, I never got beyond simple greetings.  We were never able to communicate verbally in Arabic, but the Lord provided other means.  The young girls among the Bedouin who attended school were all able to speak English.  The children and I would go the one and half hour each way trip into the dessert to visit then about twice a week.  They did not question why we would want to be their friends and come to sit with them in very modest homes without air conditioning.   They considered themselves a superior people who took great pride in their way of worship and the life they led.  They accepted us as Christians believing that we did not yet have their superior understanding.

JCarroll - 12 Lo

JCarroll - 4 Lo

The women drank tea together with me.  As I got to know them better they would take off their coverings. Although they also allowed me to photograph them without their niqab, I would never betray them by showing these photos to others outside our family.

Our children joined their children playing in the desert, antagonizing snakes and other desert creatures.

JCarroll - 25 Lo

They allowed me to help pick the bugs out of the rice for dinner.  As we got to know them, the elder among the women (Um Salem) allowed me to take her and some others in my car to go shopping.  I left the children in God’s care with the other Bedouins as we went to the souq to shop.

The peak of our relationship was when we were invited to be a part of a wedding of one of the girls.  They had a special dress made for me and told me what to get for the children.  Jim celebrated with the men while we danced with the bride.

The Bedouins knew how to rejoice and find joy in living.  They welcomed strangers because they were confident of their position in life.  They considered themselves a richly blessed people.  They were able to show hospitality to strangers because they knew they had much to give.  Wilfred Thesiger, who lived among the Bedouins of the Arabian Peninsula, wrote of them in Arabian Sands, “I shall always remember how often I was humbled by those illiterate herdsmen who possessed, in so much greater measure than I, generosity and courage, endurance, patience, and lighthearted gallantry. Among no other people have I ever felt the same sense of personal inadequacy.” I find it sad that the Bedouin way of life is fading away in the name of progress.

 

What Happened to the Marsh Arabs?

For more than a thousand years the marsh Arabs of southern Iraq persisted in the Tigris-Euphrates delta. When we think of an Arab, the Bedouin of the desert often comes to mind. But the marsh Arabs of the Ma’dan tribe built their lives around the marsh with their hunting, water buffalo and agriculture. Their population reached the hundreds of thousands.

marsh

The above photo was taken before 1991.  Saddam drained the marshes and displaced the inhabitants following the Shia uprising in southern Iraq after the first Gulf war. The marsh had been a refuge for those who opposed Saddam. Further, the marsh Arabs had long been known for their resistance to outside interference, and hence, they were obvious victims of Saddam’s need to regain control of Iraq.

The people of this area were chronicled by Wilfred Thesiger in his classic, The Marsh Arabs ,and by Gavin Maxwell in his poetic work A Reed Shaken by the Wind. The photo below was taken when we visited the marsh Arabs in the summer of 2003 after the Second Iraq war. The reed house shown here is typical of their dwellings.

Iraq-Dave 089 copy

The photo below shows the marsh filling again (2003), and the marsh Arabs began to return to their homeland, perhaps in the tens of thousands.

Iraq-Dave 118 copy

Our medical team traveled north from Kuwait City, over the border staying in Basra, and then up to Nasirriya where we worked, under military guard, with the people of the marsh. Infant malnutrition was terrible and unrecorded by authorities. Their toughness had not diminished, and they were desperate for medical care. There were no mosques, and the people were bereft of any remaining religious heritage.  So disconsolate were the people that our clinics verged on open combat. When we lagged behind the pace they wanted, scuffles broke out, and on one  occasion an AK-47 announced their frustration. Our vehicles were partially looted including all the outside mirrors. They were a tough, rough people, their anger enhanced by years of neglect, attacks from Saddam, destruction of their homeland, and ethnic bias from their fellow Iraqis.

Perhaps we helped a few. But we had to leave. I have not been able to return.

Our visit was thirteen years ago, and I hoped as the marsh filled, their conditions would improve. But now I understand the flow of the two great rivers has diminished, from excessive damming and reduced rain, and the salt is creeping up from the Shatt Al-Arab. The salt is a time bomb for the marsh Arabs.

Verified by MonsterInsights