The Disaster that is Yemen

The Yemen disaster continues. The Saudis and the Houthi representatives appear to agree to a ceasefire, but it this genuine? The Saudis say they support the remnant of the old Hadi government, which has retreated to the southern Yemeni city of Aden.

Meanwhile, the Houthis ask for relief from the bombardment of Hodeidah,  their only effective port city. (I fondly recall swimming on the beach there and sampling the seafood in a shore dinner. But no more of this, probably ever, for me.)

The Houthis also want the airport at Sana’a to be opened, as opposed to the Hadi government desiring Aden to be the country’s main airport.

Are these disagreements resolved? i doubt it. The Saudis, under Mohammed bin Salman, seem to still want blood. And without the help of the Saudis, the Houthis, supported by Iran, will likely emerge.

The UN has stated that the famine in Yemen is the world’s worst in the last 100 years!

And the US has supported the continuation of this man-made disaster.


Contrast: Jordan v. U.S for Acceptance of Refugees

I just returned from a trip to Jordan for medical work with refugees.

Jordan is a Muslim country. The population of Jordan is about 9 million. They have taken in about 800,000 refugees. While the country has had a host of problems, they have weathered onslaught with, for the most part, with no violence.

The US is a “Christian” country. Our population is about 330 million. We have agreed. to take in only about 45,000 refugees per year.  The daily TV news from the President ramps up anti-refugee spirit among our population.

The Khashoggi Thing

By now, it’s clear Jamal Khashoggi is dead. He has been missing for more than two weeks.  And it also seems clear the Saudis were, in some way, responsible. And of the potential guilty parties, Mohammed bin Salman, is the most likely perpetrator. This sort of operation is typical for the Crown Prince. And it is likely his father, King Salman, knew nothing of the operation, which allows him plausible deniability.

What should the US do? This is the problem at hand. Aside from the pricey arms deal, the war in Yemen,  and multilevel business relationships, the real issue is that Saudi Arabia is our essential counterpoint to Iran in the Middle East. We can’t escape this part of the relationship.

While some sanctions or other such punishments may be delivered to save face for the US, we will not walk away from our overall relationship with the Saudis.

Qatar Penalized For Shia Leanings?

Saudi Arabia, Bahrain, and the UAE still persist with  their boycott of Qatar, in effect, making them the outcast of the Gulf.

The stated reason for the boycott of Qatar is that they are operative in causing unrest and interference in the governments of the Gulf. Underlying this reason is Qatar’s supposed positive relationship with Iran.

This continues as Saudi Arabia and the UAE proceed with their war on Yemen, a one-sided war in which only one combatant (the Saudis) has the means to inflict damage on the other. The US supports the Saudi war effort.

At least in part, this face-off is another facet of the age-old Sunni-Shia conflict. For most of its 1400 year history, with only isolated exceptions, this conflict has been relatively minor. There has often been intermarriage between the groups.

The question for our day is whether the present Sunni-Shia strife might erupt into something totally unanticipated

Book Review: The Shia Revival by Vali Nasr

Vali Nasr’s The Shia Revival was first published in 2006 and now in 2016 with an update. In view of the ongoing struggle in the Middle East between Sunni elements in Saudi Arabia and the Shia renewal in Iran/Iraq, the book is timely. The US disengagement in the region has only enhanced the importance of this struggle.

Nasr has laid out the political changes occurring in the Gulf. For centuries Sunnis have lorded it over the Shia, but the power vacuum in the Gulf and the untapped strength of Iran are altering the calculus. The quiet distrust of Khomeini’s cult of the personality is now more evident among Shia intellectuals in the area, and other thinkers have displaced the philosophical ideas promulgated by Khomeini. It has not been possible for the Iranian religious leaders to fend off the wonderful diversity among the people of Iran. Nasr calls the government of Iran “a tired dictatorship.” He notes that Persian is now the third most popular language on the Internet after English and Mandarin.

The Saudis fear a democratic Iran more than they fear a theocratic Iran, and the changes in the direction of democracy persist, though still relatively silent, in today’s Iran. The only force that might disrupt this trend is unwise US intervention.

I recommend Nasr’s thoughtful and beautifully written book to those who want to understand what’s really happening in Iran/Iraq. Daily news on the networks doesn’t help.

Verified by MonsterInsights